Entries categorized as 'commentary'
Wednesday 21st May, 2008 · 7 Comments

Memes must sometimes be reinforced.
Let’s get this out of the way first: Demonbane is not, by any stretch of the imagination, good. It’s a visual novel franchise adaption, and it tries to squeeze a great deal of information into a mere twelve episodes: the first episode feels like it’s playing at double-speed, the OP/rapid-fire clipshow is only one minute long and events frequently occur during the credits. Despite all this cramming, lots of extra plot, helpful explanation and some whole characters are cut to create an unfortunate ‘All There In The Manual‘ situation. I didn’t understand the conclusion (which was written especially for the anime in the first place) without the aid of Wikipedia.
(more…)
Categories: commentary · review
Tagged: comparison, demonbane, literature, lovecraft, mahou shoujo lyrical nanoha
Monday 5th May, 2008 · 16 Comments

Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha A’s features a group of magical antagonists whose combat terminology is in German, although this is by no means the only foreign language used in the series (Bardiche and Raging Heart are noted for their English, while ‘Asura’ is a Sanskrit term and so forth). Quite what the status and connotations of the German language are in Japan I’ve no idea (though I’d like to find out) so I can’t guess what the intention of the staff behind Nanoha’s German is.
(more…)
Categories: commentary · dead tree format
Tagged: code geass, language, literature, mahou shoujo lyrical nanoha, musing
Sunday 20th April, 2008 · 30 Comments

In the absence of an appropriate image, I present an image of
the search for one.
Are you sitting comfortably?
Then I’ll begin.
I was intrigued to hear that BBC Radio 4 would be touching on anime briefly this Sunday evening, although I was rather less intrigued by the fact that the coverage would be on Radio 4’s concession to children’s programming, Go4It. As you can probably tell from the way the title is spelt, Go4It is trapped by two incompatible facts: to attract its target audience it needs to be cool, but it’s on Radio 4, which is not cool.
(more…)
Categories: commentary
Tagged: bbc, gimmick, miyazaki
Sunday 13th April, 2008 · 17 Comments

It’s a mixed-up muddled-up shook-up world.
Prompted by the intricacies of the Haruhi genderswap, the vicissitudes of Minami-ke’s Mako-cakes and Baka-Raptor’s recent defiant (and probably tongue-in-cheek) statement that ‘Kyon is not a girl‘. [Regarding the above image: yes, there's version without cropping and with panties. No, I'm not posting it.] ‘Once you’ve fap’d to a trap, can you never go back?’ Granted, this subject is hardly new (here’s one example of many others’ entries on it, and here’s another) but I’m not averse to picking over the bones at someone else’s banquet. I’m a student: food really is scarce.
(more…)
Categories: commentary
Tagged: ∀ gundam, gender, gundam, trapservice
Saturday 29th March, 2008 · 14 Comments

Legend of the Galactic Heroes is too long to write neatly tied-together essays on while you’re still watching the early episodes. In fact, so much happens in just the first fifteen that for the first time in my (admittedly short) blogging life, I could actually use some episode summaries - and there aren’t any, of course. I should write some, but it would be boring and I wouldn’t be very good at it. In lieu of that, I offer you some sweeping commentary which is generally spoiler-free since I hope that I might persuade others to give this classic a try, and because anything I write further into the series will probably be spoiler-laden.
Categories: commentary
Tagged: legend of the galactic heroes, mechanical design, storytelling
Thursday 27th March, 2008 · 6 Comments

The White Devil eschews aimbots in favour of guts and friendship.
After finishing Nanoha A’s a few nights ago, I suppose I should put my thinking cap on again and examine my second dose of beamspam maho shojo goodness, attempting to produce something that bolts neatly onto the end of my previous remarks like an intellectual Dendrobium Orchis or the late application of glasses to a previously un-bespectacled girl. (Since this entry wanders a little, I felt ‘addenda’ was more appropriate than ‘addendum’.) Once again, I think I’ll write about Fate and once again I’ll use the excellent eleventh episode. (Spoilers follow the break.)
(more…)
Categories: commentary
Tagged: goblin market, literature, mahou shoujo lyrical nanoha, storytelling
Friday 21st March, 2008 · 15 Comments

So Berkles has been making me flashback to my days of studying Philosophy at school. And, at the same time, I’ve been watching Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha, partly because it has a good reputation, partly because it has ‘lyrical’ in its title and partly because one can’t watch mecha all of the time. (Entry contains spoilers.)
(more…)
Categories: commentary
Tagged: analysis, mahou shoujo lyrical nanoha, philosophy, storytelling
Thursday 20th March, 2008 · 19 Comments

This entry is dedicated to the memory of Sir Arthur C. Clarke.
Judging by the few episodes I’ve seen (how’s this for rushing to conclusions?) Legend of the Galactic Heroes is epic in scope and subject - and title: in its English rendering, ‘Legend’, ‘Galactic’ and ‘Heroes’ all convey the scale of the show. This isn’t the debased ‘epic’ bandied around on imageboards. This is the real deal. It may be the first time I’ve encountered an anime which has seemed truly Virgilian - I’d say Homeric, but I think in its awareness of war’s victims, its solemn stateliness and its focus on empire(s) the Legend is much closer to the Aeneid than the Iliad.
(more…)
Categories: commentary · fanboy
Tagged: close reading, legend of the galactic heroes, literature, virgil
Tuesday 18th March, 2008 · 7 Comments

It’s time to rehabilitate this chap.
So I was watching Char’s Counter Attack the other night (well, early morning) and considering Char. Why do I find him so compelling? It was then that it struck me: Char is not so very different from everyone’s favourite sketchily-drawn (and for once I mean that literally rather than figuratively) villain, the Anti-Spiral. I’ll grant that this isn’t the most obvious point of Gundam comparison for Tengen Toppa Gurren-Lagann (’This drill of mine whirs with an awesome POWER’ et cetera, et cetera), but I think the connection is fruitful. As you might expect, this post is laden with spoilers; enter at your own risk. (more…)
Categories: commentary
Tagged: analysis, anti-spiral, char aznable, char's counter attack, comparison, genderswap, gundam, tengen toppa gurren lagann
Sunday 16th March, 2008 · 31 Comments

It’s a bit like another Judgement of Paris¹
I finally thought I had conquered the urge to compare what are probably anime’s two most prominent mecha franchises, and Washi had to go and open the contrast-floodgates which I had just managed to close. Of course, I haven’t seen enough of either to properly do the job justice (Kaioshin ought to write this), but sometimes in life we simply have to use the best tools we have to hand, just as sometimes in anime we simply have to rely on the untrained teenager who’s been accidentally thrust into the cockpit of the military’s latest toy. (more…)
Categories: commentary · fanboy
Tagged: gundam, macross, mobile suit gundam, sdf macross