The Animanachronism

Entries categorized as 'review'

Demonbane, Nanoha and the Cosmic Horrors

Wednesday 21st May, 2008 · 7 Comments

Referential
Memes must sometimes be reinforced.

Let’s get this out of the way first: Demonbane is not, by any stretch of the imagination, good. It’s a visual novel franchise adaption, and it tries to squeeze a great deal of information into a mere twelve episodes: the first episode feels like it’s playing at double-speed, the OP/rapid-fire clipshow is only one minute long and events frequently occur during the credits. Despite all this cramming, lots of extra plot, helpful explanation and some whole characters are cut to create an unfortunate ‘All There In The Manual‘ situation. I didn’t understand the conclusion (which was written especially for the anime in the first place) without the aid of Wikipedia.

(more…)

Categories: commentary · review
Tagged: , , , ,

Manga Most Strange

Saturday 17th May, 2008 · 15 Comments

Reverse Trap Hamlet
I’ve used this before, but the internet needs more reverse trap Hamlet.

I have an unsubstantiated theory that any boys who encounter Hamlet during their adolescence will become slightly obsessed with the play. It is very easy to read Hamlet as a misanthropic, withdrawn and rather ‘emo’ teenager, and - though this would seem very alien to the original audience, who lacked the concept - it’s no surprise that 21st century teenagers identify with him.

You can probably detect the voice of personal experience here, though I no longer identify with Hamlet in quite that way. For a start, although his age is much-disputed, there is textual evidence for a rather older Hamlet. And withdrawn teenagers are, for the most part, boring. But the obsession itself is harder to escape; to this day, productions of the play have me reaching for my wallet with the same irrational fervour that others use for figurines. (’Ooh, look! A 1:8 Ophelia, “distracted, playing on a lute, and her hair down, singing“!’)

And so it is that we come to Self Made Hero’s ‘Manga Shakespeare’ version of Hamlet. It’s a strange (though hardly the strangest) concept. Curiosity drove me to buy it. But is it manga? Is it Hamlet? And what’s it actually like?

(more…)

Categories: dead tree format · review
Tagged: ,

Kimikiss Ends, Says Surprisingly Little

Monday 24th March, 2008 · 5 Comments

A Kiss To Send Us Off!

So Kimikiss departs on the 01:36 am Steam Train of Storytelling, while I’m left standing on the Foggy Platform of Real Life, manfully adjusting my Starched Collar of Essay-Composition and emitting stiff-upper-lipped Throat-Clearings of ‘I’m not crying’.¹ I suppose writing a blog entry about it is akin to listening to the departing rattle of the rolling stock and smelling the soot on the air. To quickly jump between transport metaphors, I’m also sad to see CCY standing at the wheel of the Yuumi x Kouichi liner, having honourably overseen the evacuation of all the passengers, disappearing beneath the waves but never deserting his ’ship. (Hooray for doujins, eh? Eh?)

(more…)

Categories: review
Tagged: , ,

Ecole du Ciel Vol. 1: A GCSE in Gundam?

Sunday 17th February, 2008 · 4 Comments

Characters

I don’t read enough manga. It’s not that I dislike it, it’s that I find it hard to relax with a book, or more specifically with the physical shape of a book, a codex. To ‘come home after a hard day’s reading and relax with a book’ carries a certain contradiction, as I’m sure you can see.

But I try. After all, manga has a number of practical advantages over anime as a form of entertainment: it’s much cheaper, and it’s available in the UK pretty much as soon as it’s available in the US because (glory be!) books don’t have those pesky Region Code thingies. [Wouldn't life be awful if they did?]

Credit is therefore due to Kaoishin-sama for putting me onto Ecole du Ciel. Ecole has what it takes to interest me: obscurity value, curiosity value and hawt Mobile Suit-on-Mobile Suit action value. Plus the manga-ka is Mikimoto Haruhiko, who has an impressive set of character design credits including a number of Macrosses (and the animation direction for Do You Remember Love?) and War in the Pocket. And the first volume arrived in my letterbox recently, so here I am talking about it. (more…)

Categories: dead tree format · review
Tagged: , , , ,

Seven Mingin’ Monsters

Thursday 20th December, 2007 · 2 Comments

Squish!

On the seventh day of Christmas, my true love sent to me
Seven Mingin’ Monsters

Six Shower Showdowns,
Five Flag Furores,
Four Gundam Bishies,
Three Empty Paragraphs,
Two Heroes Dueling
And a Bloodstained Euphie. (more…)

Categories: fanboy · review
Tagged: , ,

Mechademia Vol. 1

Saturday 8th December, 2007 · 11 Comments

One of the pleasures of a good university library is the periodicals section, offering the very latest in whichever field you happen to be studying, and often carrying articles from less established academics who are (whisper it) closer in age to an undergraduate than your average professor is. Periodicals are also, of course, the bleeding edge - there’s more experimentation, risk and (occasionally) failure to be found in them than in weighty hardback tomes.

My response when I heard about Mechademia was predictable: any journal which unites one of my interests with cultural commentary, which is in essence my degree subject (admittedly, I study the out-of-date written culture of my own country, not the up-to-date visual culture of another country), was a must-read. (more…)

Categories: dead tree format · review
Tagged: